BBC's Watchdog PS3 Show FAIL
Ridiculous farce of a 'show'
Posted 18 Sept 2009
Follow us on...
Share on...
Tags
Here's just a flavour of the reasoned approach taken by the Beeb to faults found in some pre-Slim PS3 Phats.
"Iain Lee maybe a self-declared Xbox man with a regular column on the Microsoft Network but he was just as interested as we were to hear that there was a potential fix for the PS3 Yellow Light of Death."
This would appear to us to be the balanced equivalent of sending a vegetarian to talk about making pork pies tastier and porkier.
The show - we think - was attempting to point out that: some PS3 Phats fail; that this is indicated by a yellow (amber) light; that Sony refused to pin down the fault to a specific issue; that Watchdog's specialist team of two guys could fix every faulty PS3 because they all actually have the same (solder-based) problem; that Sony charge for repairs after the one year warranty expires.
So, basically, there's a specific fault in some PS3 Phats, (apparently 12,500 that Sony "admitted to... but it could be so much more!!" according the Watchdog's reasoned approach) that Sony won't admit to.
The Sony spokesperson invited onto the show... nope, there wasn't one. Apparently Sony refused to appear on the show "due to concerns the tone of the programme would ridicule its defence and it would not receive fair treatment" according to GI.biz.
While Sony charges (frankly, a lot) for out of warranty repairs, we weren't informed how much Watchdog's specialist team - named PlayStation Repair Action Team (yes, P.R.A.T.) - charged for repairs.
In short, a show that could have said, "Come on SCEEUK! There's a fault. Admit to it" and brought a SCEUK spokesperson on, descended into a mishmash of poor research, apparent bias, and a daft song at the end.
You can watch the entire show in iPlayer (on your PS3) for the next seven days. We've also included lowlights at the foot of this story.
You can also read our take on fixing a borked PS3 here - it's much calmer.
Comments
Showing the most recent 20 comments. Go to the forum to read all 24 comments
6/24
Adverts are coming to the BBC and now this?!
This stinks of an under-the-table deal with Microsoft.
This stinks of an under-the-table deal with Microsoft.
more comments below our sponsor's message
7/24
Thing that probably created the problem is the BBC sacking Nicky Campbell and the other very proficient team to hire Anne Robinson because she is more edgy - nonsense breeds nonsense. Watchdog was a good show now it's a mess. Nicky always said "we asked ____ if they wanted to come on the show but they declined" or they were in the studio, bureacracy!
8/24
They forgot to mention that, the xbox 360 used to have the EXACT SAME PROBLEM called the 'RING OF DEATH'
I own a PS3, 360 & a Wii, and my 360 broke TWICE because of this EXACT same problem the ps3 is having (altho my ps3 has never broke)
I fixed my xbox the same way the prat guys did with those ps3's, so very harsh to just point the finger at sony!
I own a PS3, 360 & a Wii, and my 360 broke TWICE because of this EXACT same problem the ps3 is having (altho my ps3 has never broke)
I fixed my xbox the same way the prat guys did with those ps3's, so very harsh to just point the finger at sony!
9/24
I'm on my 3rd PS3 60 GB.
I'mbeating the 0.5% failure rate by some margin.
I'mbeating the 0.5% failure rate by some margin.
10/24
@Michael_Lee
I have had no failures, and neither has my father in law, so we are at 0%. Maybe you should take more care!
I have had no failures, and neither has my father in law, so we are at 0%. Maybe you should take more care!
11/24
All major companies seem to get faults with their devices/software, over hyped by the news these days, the majority of which would normally be resolved by the company anyway without any big deal.
Also, the new series of Watchdog is very poor, the new format is ridiculous. Yes, at times the previous ones have been sensentional at times but at least they seemd to get things solved from time to time.
Also, the new series of Watchdog is very poor, the new format is ridiculous. Yes, at times the previous ones have been sensentional at times but at least they seemd to get things solved from time to time.
12/24
Why do any of you care. I hate sycophants!!!
13/24
@Me
a sycophant is "a self-seeking, servile flatterer; fawning parasite". I think you will find we are all bitching about the crap reporting on the BBC, which makes us more critic than sycophant.
a sycophant is "a self-seeking, servile flatterer; fawning parasite". I think you will find we are all bitching about the crap reporting on the BBC, which makes us more critic than sycophant.
14/24
I dismissed the entire thing the moment I read "Iain Lee". What a nobber.
15/24
I suck big nobs for cash
16/24
Well with any hardware of any type their will always be a certain failure rate. 1 Year is pretty much standard for any electrinix device. I think the main things is to try to keep it to low percentages. The show really did not seem to do much research, no real statistics or even any real details. They seem so hung up their fix which they admit is only 50% reliable.
17/24
@Iain_Lee "In hindsight, taking part in watchdog was an obvious mistake. It is clear that the facts do not line up. The overzealous and rash attempt to show the PS3 in a poor light was based on poor journalism and a low number of systems reviewed."
That's understandable, but how did you manage to take part in it without knowing how the BBC were going to spin it? Did they simply ask you to do the outdoor stunt? To be fair, you're only in it for that bit so I can get why you probably wouldn't know about the poor journalism you mentioned.
That's understandable, but how did you manage to take part in it without knowing how the BBC were going to spin it? Did they simply ask you to do the outdoor stunt? To be fair, you're only in it for that bit so I can get why you probably wouldn't know about the poor journalism you mentioned.
18/24
I tried to fix as many of these faulty PS3s as i could by rubbing them on my big fat donkey balls whilst Anne Robinson gave me a "Rusty Trombone",
Rusty trombone is a euphemism for a sexual act in which a man stands with his knees and back slightly bent, with feet at least shoulder width apart in order to expose the anus.[1] The other partner typically kneels behind the man and performs anilingus while reaching up beneath the testicles or around the body to masturbate the man, mimicking the motions of a trombone player.[1][2] The act is defined primarily by the physical orientation of the partners and the combination of analingus with manual penile stimulation; however, other positions and variations are possible.
Rusty trombone is a euphemism for a sexual act in which a man stands with his knees and back slightly bent, with feet at least shoulder width apart in order to expose the anus.[1] The other partner typically kneels behind the man and performs anilingus while reaching up beneath the testicles or around the body to masturbate the man, mimicking the motions of a trombone player.[1][2] The act is defined primarily by the physical orientation of the partners and the combination of analingus with manual penile stimulation; however, other positions and variations are possible.
19/24
People slag off MS for their 20 odd percent failure rate and their 35 to 40 quid a yr xbox live cost but when your console breaks, they pay to collect, fix and return the console to you without arguement. I sent mine away and had a new one back within 2 weeks and it went all the way to germany to be fixed. If that isnt efficient i dont know what is!
Sony have to learn a lesson from microsoft this time
Sony have to learn a lesson from microsoft this time
20/24
Yo Iain Lee, I'm really happy for you and Imma let you finish your sloppy, unresearched, sensationalist bile here real soon but Anne Robinson was the best Watchdog presenter of all time.
21/24
I lold at the show, it was so retardedly bad it was funny.
22/24
Hi there, The head of the BBC here, I'd just like to aplogise for Mr Lee's Comments on the page here.
Mr Lee has had a 50% pay cut to his 10 million salary and all internet cut off for 5 days, Hopefully he's learnt his lesson now.
To try and make it back up to you all, I'd like to present Anne Robertson felching Gordon Brown after he's taken a load from Mr Darling.
Mr Lee has had a 50% pay cut to his 10 million salary and all internet cut off for 5 days, Hopefully he's learnt his lesson now.
To try and make it back up to you all, I'd like to present Anne Robertson felching Gordon Brown after he's taken a load from Mr Darling.
23/24
Come one we all know Spong.com is run by a Sony fanbos, it's why are you all over this like a rash.
24/24
aa wrote:
Come one we all know Spong.com is run by a Sony fanbos, it's why are you all over this like a rash.
Oh, my sides are full of painful laughter. Firstly, when did you represent "all". Secondly, we're not. Thirdly, Sony definitely doesn't think we are.
regards
Tim
Related News
Latest Features
| Interview// F1 2009: David Croft and Anthony Davidson |
| Review// Assassin's Creed II |
| Interview// SCEE's Alison Turner on the PSN Video Store |
| Interview// F1 2009: Sumo Digital's Ned Waterhouse |
That's because a 0.5% failure rate is low for consumer electronics. There isn't a "problem" just the usual batch of failures. MS had to acknowledge that their console was very poorly designed and made and offer assistance otherwise nobody would have bought one.